Public Sector Pay Battle

We are in a battle.

We are in a class war with the representatives of capital. The government and the employers are not our ‘partners’ as they claim. They never voluntarily make concessions. They only concede when we fight and when we strike.

After 40 years of pay deals, they saw the unions as soft. They faced little resistance to the systematic shredding of basic conditions in the public sector between 2008-2015 and concluded that they never would again. They were wrong. Facing soaring fuel prices, ongoing inflation, an AI bubble, they decided to make us pay. Wrong again.

But we didn’t retreat.

They allowed the last pay deal to lapse but then were stunned by the huge mandate for strike action from public sector workers. The government’s response was to drag out talks and to make an insulting offer of only 6.75% over 30 months plus an extra 2% local bargaining.

Martin, Harris, O’Callaghan, Chambers et al. faced massive strike action on the day of their big EU showpiece, with angry workers on the streets and enormous support from the wider working class.

We pushed back and gained ground

We have to have a sober understanding of what was – and was not – achieved.

We went from an offer of 6.75% (and 2%) over 30 months to 9.75% (and 1%) over 33 months – a significant advance.  The deal gives all those earning under €60,000 (approx. 200,000 workers) higher increases – a maximum of 18.3% for those on the lowest pay, and a sliding scale as salaries climb to €60,000. In all cases, the increase exceeds forecast inflation, if only marginally for those on higher incomes.

It is important, too, to recognise that there is an inflation review clause in the deal – in case inflation rises significantly higher in the next 33 months. Unions must stand ready to activate this clause – including, as in 2022, balloting for industrial action if the government refuses to engage.

And there is protection against compulsory redundancies and to a more limited extent against outsourcing.

But the truth is that this deal does not compensate us all for what we have lost to inflation over the last five years – a stated goal of the union leaderships.

So, what was – and is – possible?

Virtually all of the union leaders call for a Yes vote and many of the executive bodies will vote the same on the basis that this was the best offer that could be achieved at this stage through negotiations.

Others will call for a No vote, insisting that further strike action will gain further ground.

We have this decision to make. A calm appraisal of the situation, of our strength, of their strength, of what we hold, and of what we stand to win or lose is essential.

What is certain?

This has been just one battle in a continuing war. There will be other battles, and probably very soon – the government has plainly made the decision to go on the offensive, and one bloody nose won’t stop them. The days of quietly negotiated public sector deals are now clearly over for good. Industrial action, strikes, protests and confrontation will now be a factor for all workers in all future clashes with employers. Workers and unions need to reckon with this political fact and prepare now. Building the capacity for serious, prolonged and militant struggle will require a fundamental change in how unions organize. Politically preparing members for this kind of struggle is now an urgent task within unions across the economy.

If workers vote to accept this deal, the government will hope that strike action on pay is unlikely over the next 33 months. The day-to-day tasks of building our unions’ strength and their fighting capacity will remain. The conduct of this dispute by the leadership of the trade union movement has demonstrated weaknesses. The lack of a clear pay demand from the start; the inadequate communication; and lack of consultation of members on how it has been fought. These all highlight the need for much greater union democratisation.

If workers vote against the deal then we quickly need to prepare the sort of struggle which will force significant concessions from this government. Key to that will be building for an escalated strategy of strike action with the clear goal of reversing the losses of the last decade.

What next?

We need to focus on building our strength for the inevitable coming conflicts. The powerful mobilisation of workers on October 14th shows the enthusiasm of union members. That needs to be channelled through increased lay democracy and the re-establishment of functioning workplace branches. Building, and rebuilding, our unions in the workplace and in our society requires involving new activists, holding regular meetings and establishing a network of shop stewards.

The recent events have demonstrated the need to build a strong, coherent Left in the unions, independent of the leaders, to hold them to account, and fighting for the interests of members and against the corrosive fiction of partnership with capitalists and their government.

Most importantly still, the recent struggle has confirmed the burning need for a party of working people to act in our interests and to fight for the sort of socialist change needed to really transform our lives.